| |
Background
Information:
Since 1996, a community based organization called Inter-Community
Development (ICODEI) has been implementing community development
programs in the rural villages where large international aid programs
have never been. The vision of the leaders of ICODEI has become a
reality through their partnerships with 5 student organizations in the
United States, one of them being IFMSA.
Our main area of focus since 1996 has been AIDS Education. On a
shoestring budget with no source of external funding, we have managed to
sensitize over 48,000 Kenyans about the transmission and prevention of
HIV/AIDS. During June of 2001, our team constructed and opened the first
public library in Western Kenya (Kabula location), with the potential of
serving the 800,000 people of the area in the future. Our team also
constructed a preschool in June of 2001 and established a "Sponsor
a Child's Education" program to assist those children whose
families cannot afford to send them to school. Recognizing that Kenyan
women in rural areas often lack access to credit, we have also organized
an income-generating program for the local women. Over 2,000 women from
62 different women's groups organized into 4 consortia for the purpose
of establishing sewing and tailoring centers during the summers of 2001
and 2002. Each consortium was given 5 sewing machines to begin their
businesses. Through a partnership with the Foundation for International
Education (USA) in 1999, we established a Teacher’s Program that
offers students and experienced teachers the opportunity to come to
Kenya and teach in the local schools. Between June 10th and June 15th, a
group of medical students from the United States set up a temporary
health clinic in the Library and managed to start medical records for
487 people and distributed 24,000 vitamins. Construction of a clinic at
the same Kabula location was started simultaneously with this exercise
and is expected to be complete by early August, 2002. The clinic will be
staffed by local health care professionals, as well as those
volunteering from abroad. The projected date of opening the clinic is
December 1st, 2002.
Concerned
Health Professional:
The people living in the rural areas of Western Kenya are facing
major obstacles in their pursuit of adequate health care. Although
several government run hospitals do exist in the Western Province, they
are not adequately equipped to handle the needs of the people. The two
major problems are related to the shortage health care professionals and
to the access of medications due to availability and financial
restrictions. By establishing a Health Education Center and Clinic in
Kabula, Kenya, we hope to alleviate some of these problems. From our
first hand experiences we have seen unsuccessful development projects
that failed due to the donor organizations unwillingness to work with
the local people. Therefore, to promote sustainable development, we will
assist the current infrastructure by working hand in hand with the local
health care providers in a mutually beneficial exchange. By working in a
non-imposing manner, the clinic will be maintained by the local health
care providers even in the absence of members from the donor
organization.
In the United States, there exist 341 people per doctor, while in
the East African nation of Kenya, there are an astounding 10,150 people
per doctor. It deserves mentioning that these figures are averages,
meaning that in some rural areas throughout Kenya and other parts of
Africa there may be over 100,000 people per doctor. Please peruse the
following table. The number of human beings per doctor can serve as a
general indicator of access to health care in any given country.
Therefore, by examining this figure, one can locate the countries in the
world that are the most disadvantaged with respect to access to health
care.
Table 1: People per Physician1
|
Country
|
Region
|
People per Physician
|
|
Burkina Faso
|
W Africa
|
57310
|
|
Ethiopia
|
E Africa
|
32500
|
|
Cambodia
|
SE Asia
|
27000
|
|
Tanzania
|
E Africa
|
24970
|
|
Nepal
|
NW Asia
|
16830
|
|
Kenya
|
E Africa
|
10150
|
|
Philippines
|
SE Asia
|
8120
|
|
Jamaica
|
C America
|
6159
|
|
India
|
NW Asia
|
2460
|
|
Honduras
|
C America
|
3090
|
|
Bolivia
|
S America
|
2124
|
|
United States
|
N America
|
341
|
Nearly
14 million children under five years of age still die annually in
developing countries. Diarrhea, measles, tetanus, pertussis, pneumonia,
and malnutrition are preventable and treatable and yet account for the
majority of deaths (6). Infectious diarrhea is the most common
infectious disease syndrome worldwide resulting in more than five
million deaths annually, a higher rate than cancer and AIDS combined
(7). According to the World Health Organization (WHO), every year more
than three million children die in Africa from vaccine-preventable
diseases. The results from 53 developing countries with nationally
representative data on child weight-for-age indicate that 56% of child
deaths were attributable to malnutrition's devastating effects, and 83%
of these were attributable to mild-to-moderate as opposed to severe
malnutrition (5). With the knowledge that 98% of all deaths in children
younger than 15 years and that 83% of deaths in people between 15 and 59
are in developing countries, it is evident that some action must be
taken (4).
In Kenya, there is on average one doctor per 500 people in
Nairobi, but only one per 160,000 in rural Turkana district (3). Health
facilities are often located in urban areas, far away from rural
populations most in need, or are not accessible to large numbers of the
population via public transportation. Besides the issue of lack of
access to health care, the people in rural areas also face the harsh
reality they may be unable to afford the medications prescribed by the
doctor. More than 900 million human beings worldwide make less than $1 a
day. In developing countries, corruption is often rampant and funding
with good intentions never reaches the people at the grassroots that are
in need. World Bank estimates that for every $100 spent by African
governments on drugs, only $12 worth of medicines reaches patients (3).
Why
assist developing countries when there are still millions of Americans
in need?
With over 45 million citizens of the United States
lacking health insurance, the question of "Why assist developing
countries" arises. This figure definitely indicates that there
exists a need for health care assistance in the United States. However,
the barriers to health care in developing countries such as Kenya are
much more numerous, greater in magnitude and more complex than in
developed countries.
Demonstrating
a Need:
In a random sample survey taken by community members of Kabula,
Kenya during the summer of 2001, 66% of the respondents reported that
the most common reason they sought medical care was due to suspicion of
acquiring malaria or typhoid fever. When asked, "What is the
primary factor that prevents you from seeking medical treatment that may
be necessary or beneficial?" 53% responded "high cost of
treatment" and 39% responded "long distance to medical
facility." In an attempt to survey the community members' attitude
towards and desire to obtain medical care, the people were asked,
"If cheaper basic medical services were available in Kabula, how
often would you use them?" 88% responded "2 or 3 times a
month", thus indicating that the people do desire improved access
to health care. When asked, "If cheaper basic medical services were
available in Kabula, which services would you be most likely to
utilize?" 85% responded with "diagnosis of malaria or
typhoid." From this information, it is evident that the following
medications would be beneficial to have in large supplies:
-
Ampicillin,
trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole and ciprofloxacin for the treatment of
typhoid fever
-
Mefloquine (Lariam), Malarone,
and Fansidar for the prevention and treatment of malaria
-
Antibiotics
Given the high prevalence of diseases that are
preventable by vaccination such as typhoid fever, we hope to be able to
begin a vaccination program for local community members once the Health
Clinic has progressed through its early stages of operation.
Description
of the Clinic:
Between
June 10th and June 15th, a group of medical students from the United
States set up a temporary health clinic in the Library and managed to
start medical records for 487 people and distributed 24,000 vitamins.
Construction of a clinic at the same Kabula location was started
simultaneously with this exercise. The structure that has been
erected during the summer of 2002 was done so with a budget of
approximately $8,300 USD. The clinic consists of 5 examination rooms, a
nurses’ station, an office, front desk, medical records office,
waiting room and 2 storage rooms. Currently we have no electricity or
running water. For now, one of the exam rooms will be used for a HIV
Pre/Post Test Counseling Office, and another exam room will be used for
the laboratory. We will set up a temporary pharmacy in one of the
storage rooms. Until the clinic has been in operation for several
months, this work will be contracted to a Pharmacy from a larger town.
We are planning on an expansion during the summer of 2003. People
visiting the clinic will be charged a nominal fee of less than $1 USD,
which will also cover treatment of minor ailments. This fee is about
what someone would have to pay just in transportation costs to get to
the nearest hospital 13 km away. Other treatment and/or lab tests will
be an additional fee. The clinic will have five full time employees: a
clinical officer, a nurse, a lab tech, a front desk clerk, and an
accountant/office manager. With the fees generated from the office
visits, 21 people a day will need to visit the clinic in order to
generate the necessary $25,000 KSh per month (~$333USD) for the total
salaries of the employees. We are planning on raising funds for the
first 3 months salaries ($1,000 USD total), and then feel the clinic
will be sustainable after this time period.
Our goal is to make the clinic a rotation site that welcomes
medical students, nurses, doctors and other health professionals from
abroad that are interested in assisting and experiencing medicine in
rural Africa.
June
10th-15th Medical Check-ups Statistics:
-
Total
Records:
487
-
Visual
Problems:
37
-
Dental
Problems:
47
-
Surgical
Candidate:
11
-
Needs
Nutritional Support:
20
-
Dermatological
Problems:
33
-
Infectious
Disease Screen:
34
-
Desires
HIV Test:
32
-
Unique/Needs
Follow-up:
103
Clinic
Employees’ Salaries:
-
Clinical
Officer:
8,000 KSh/month
-
Nurse:
6,000 KSh/month
-
Lab
Technician:
3,500 KSh/month
-
Front
Desk Clerk:
2,500 KSh/month
-
Accountant/Office
Manager:
5,000 KSh/month
-
Total:
25,000 KSh/month (~$333 USD/month)
*To get a rough estimate for conversion to
US Dollars, you can divide the amount of Kenya Schillings (KSh) by 75.
**The following positions may be added at a
later date depending on the situation:
-
Nurse
Aid:
3,000 KSh/month
-
Pharmacists’
Assistant:
3,000 KSh/month
-
HIV
Counselor:
3,000 KSh/month
***We will need 3 months of salary saved before we
open the clinic. This will give us time to get everything organized and
operational. After this initial 3 month time period, the clinic will be
self-sustaining based on the nominal fee each person will pay for an
office visit. The details are listed in the following section.
Clinic
Fees:
Each person visiting the clinic will be required to
pay 70 KSh (93 cents) to see the Clinical Officer and/or Doctor. Please
note that for transport alone to the nearest hospital or clinic, the
people have to pay a minimum of 40 KSh. Of this 70 KSh:
-
20
KSh can be used for treatment of simple ailments
-
50
KSh will be used for maintenance of the Clinic and Staff salaries
Example: Malaria can be treated for 18 KSh
-
Fansidar:
10 KSh
-
Paracetamol:
3 KSh
-
Injection:
5 KSh
Laboratory
Fees:
The income generated from laboratory work will be
used for stocking the lab, buying supplies for the clinic, and possibly
for the salary of an HIV Counselor. The following are the most common
test performed and their respective process:
-
Malaria
test:
30 KSh
-
Typhoid
Test:
80 KSh
-
Brucella
Test:
80 KSh
Sustainability
of the Clinic:
If you treat 500 people per month at a rate of 50 KSh of income
per patient, the clinic will need to treat 21 people a day, and be open
24 days a month. Hours of operation will be Monday through Saturday,
from 8am to 5pm. Using this equation, the clinic will generate the
necessary 25,000 KSh per month for the salaries of the staff.
Immediate
Expenses:
As mentioned previously, the clinic does not have electricity
or running water. Before the clinic can pass inspection by the Ministry
of Health in Kenya, we need to rectify this situation. Our immediate
expenses are as follows:
-
Solar
Panels (Two 40 watt panels, inverter, batteries X2):
97,440 KSh ($1,299)
-
Electrical
Wiring (outlets, switches, sockets, labor): 9,000 KSh ($120)
-
Plumbing
(2 toilets, 7 sinks, 960L Water Tank, piping, 2,300 L septic tank,
labor): 122,000 KSh ($1,627)
-
Plaster
outside walls (cement, sand and labor): 22,000 KSh
($293)
-
Initial
3 months salaries: $75,000 KSh
($1,000)
-
Additional
furniture: 31,000 KSh ($413)
-
Total:
$4,752 USD
Summer
of 2003 Expansion:
Our goal is to expand the clinic during the summer of 2003. We
plan on building another structure adjacent to the present building.
Once this building is complete, we will move the HIV Pre/Post Test
Counseling Office, the Laboratory, and the Pharmacy to the new building.
This will then mean all 5 of the examination rooms will be available for
the patients. The new building will also include an operating room and
an administrative office. Local contractors have quoted a price of
approximately $25,000 USD for this expansion. We plan on adding a second
floor to house an “In-patient” ward at some point in the future.
Depending on the fundraising efforts and grants, this may occur during
the summer of 2003 or summer of 2004.
Desired
Diagnostic Equipment List:
|
BP
Monitor
|
Blood-Glucose
Monitor
|
|
Calorimeter
|
Laparoscope
|
|
Centrifuge
|
Coulter
Counter
|
|
Culture
& Sensitivity incubator
|
HIV
Testing Kits
|
|
L.C.G.
monitor
|
Ultra
Sound
|
|
Microscope(s)
|
Oximeter
|
|
Needle destroyer
|
Nebulizer
|
|
Operating
table and lights
|
Anesthesia
equipment
|
|
Opthalmoscope(s)
|
Otoscope(s)
|
|
Sphygmomanometer(s)
|
Syringes
|
|
Spirometer
|
ECG
Machine
|
|
Stethoscope(s)
|
Thermometer
|
|
Sutures
|
Autoclave
|
|
X-ray
machine
|
Vaccine
fridge
|
Organizations
Involved:
Inter-Community Development Involvement (ICODEI) works closely
with the following organizations in the United States:
-
The
International Federation of Medical Students’ Association
-
Humanitarian
Medical Outreach of Rice University
-
United
Trauma Relief of Massachusetts Institute of Technology
-
Outreach
Kenya Development Volunteers of Indiana University
-
Outreach
Kenya Development Volunteers of West Virginia University
As you can see, there are currently many organizations and
sustainable community development projects being implemented in the
Western Province of Kenya. Through our experiences in development work,
we have found it to be very beneficial to work hand in hand with the
local people at the grassroots level. These are the people and areas of
rural Africa that are seldom reached by International Aid programs.
While the Western press highlights the dismal failures and corruption of
the leaders and the elites in the African countries, they are
overlooking the resilience of the people at the grass-roots level. We
have met many groups of Kenyans who refuse to remain idle, who refuse to
wait for someone from the outside to give them a grant or a four-wheel
drive vehicle, who have taken matters into their own hands. In working
with Rev. Lubanga, the women's groups, and the HIV/AIDS drama teams, we
realized that an abundance of hope does exist in Kenya. And this hope
resides in the people; the people who live in the grass roots, who are
self-confident, resilient, and unnoticed, but who continue to develop
and improve their communities. It is this group of people that we will
continue to work with hand in hand, and it is with these people Kenya's
future rests--a future that is much brighter than many realize.
Donations:
To
make a tax-deductible donation to the Clinic, please make checks payable
to IFMSA-USA and write Kenya Clinic in the Memo. Send all checks to the
following address:
IFMSA-USA National Headquarters
PO Box 1990
Philadelphia, PA 19105-1990
*If at all possible when making a donation, please
contact Hank Selke (812-219-1054 or hankselke@hotmail.com)
alerting him of the donor's name, address, email address and the
amount of the donation.
For
more information, please contact:
Hank Selke
1323
University St.
Bloomington,
IN 47401
Phone:
(812) 219-1054
Email: hankselke@hotmail.com
Web
site: www.volunteerkenya.org
References
 |
The
World Health Organization: Statistical Information System http://www.who.int/whosis
|
 |
The Bureau of Primary Health
Care: http://www.bphc.hrsa.dhhs.gov |
 |
Pharmaceutical Research and
Manufacturers of America: http://www.phrma.org/ |
 |
Lopez, Murray. Mortality by
cause for eight regions of the world: Global Burden of Disease
Study. Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Lancet 1997 May 3;349 (9061):1269-76 |
 |
Pelletier DL, Frongillo EA Jr,
Schroeder DG, Habicht JP. The effects of malnutrition on child
mortality in developing countries. Division of Nutritional Sciences,
Cornell University, Ithaca, New York 14853, USA. Bull World Health
Organ 1995;73(4):443-8 |
 |
Nahata, MC. Status of child
health worldwide. Ohio State University. Ann Pharmacother 1992
Apr;26(4):559-61 |
 |
Carroll KC, Reimer L.
Infectious diarrhea: pathogens and treatment. Department of
Pathology, University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City. J
Med Liban 2000 Jul-Aug;48(4):270-7
|
|
|